Anime Taste Testing: Spring 2014 (Part II)

49. picture1
The halfway point for all but two of the spring anime shows I’m following is very nearly upon us, which must mean it’s about time for the usual first impressions follow-up post. I had already dropped a considerable number of titles last time around, and I’m sure it’ll surprise nobody to learn that some other titles have now joined them… although there’s been one surprise pick-up since then as well.

TD;LR, here are the shows I dropped after the first couple of episodes: Bokura wa Minna Kawaisou, Akuma no Riddle, Hitsugi no Chaika, Kiniro no Chord, Mekakucity Actors, Soredemo Sekai wa Utsukushii, No Game No Life, and Ping Pong. I didn’t talk about either of those last two in my original post, as I only gave them a first-episode trial last week. Neither particularly appealed (though I may well give Ping Pong a proper go when I have more time and/or patience for it), so I didn’t bother pursuing them further, and won’t be talking about them here.

Which leaves me with seven. As with last time, I’ll be starting from the bottom of the pile and working my way up to the good stuff.

Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei/The Irregular at Magic High School
Original score: 6/10
Current score: 5/10

46. picture10

Just so we’re clear, I don’t give a damn about the light novels. I’m not trying to be disrespectful – it’s just that I genuinely don’t care. I haven’t read the books, I probably never will, and as far as this post is concerned, what matters is how the anime stands as an individual creation. And on that note, I can’t say that I’ve been overly impressed thus far. The visuals are still very striking; I really like the colour palette, and the animation (when the anime can be bothered to show it off) is extremely fluid. My main issue with this series as it currently stands is that my eyes are starting to glaze over despite these things. I’ve certainly seen way worse shows (I mean, the fact that there’s even a semblance of a plot here, and that it can be followed, already makes it far better than some other titles I could mention), but I’m on the verge of dropping this one nonetheless. A certain amount of exposition is almost always inevitable, but exactly how long am I expected to watch while people stand around and talk? Even the events at the end of episode 5 fail to liven things up sufficiently enough to rouse the show from its stupor. It’s a shame, because if it weren’t for the blandly clichéd school setting, I could see this alternative fantasy universe actually going somewhere.

Kamigami no Asobi
Original score: 6.5/10
Current score: 6/10

46. picture9

If only every episode were as fabulously ridiculous as that first one! Well, I’m still here, so clearly Kamigami no Asobi manages to continue being entertaining enough in its own way, but the sheer absurdity of those first twenty minutes hasn’t made a reappearance. This series is definitely one that works best when it’s being a blatantly stupid and over-the-top parody of itself, and to some extent that’s still what’s being showcased, but it really needs to ramp up the energy again if it wants to do itself justice. It’s funny, but no longer hilarious – although everything about it is still definitely very silly, so that’s a good sign. (Additional note: if I took a drink every time Thoth trapped Yui against a wall, I’d still be hung-over as we speak.)

Black Bullet
Original score: 7/10
Current score: 6/10

46. picture8

I’m finding myself running hot and cold with this show. The first episode felt average at best, the second episode was significantly better, and the next two took it down a notch or two again. I suppose I have no major issues, since Enju stopped annoying me pretty early on and nothing is yet screaming “plot hole!” at me – although I do think there’s still some important character development that needs to happen if Black Bullet is aiming to have any sort of emotional impact. I’ll almost certainly be watching this series right the way through, but it remains to be seen whether it’s going to be just another vaguely interesting but largely forgettable action piece, or whether it’ll turn into something with a bit more uniqueness and depth than that. Ah well, either way, at least the music’s good. Best OP and ED theme of all the light novel adaptations this season.

Captain Earth
Original score: 7/10
Current score: 6.5/10

46. picture11

Captain Earth is a show that I think I want to like more than I currently actually do. It looks great, it sounds great (particularly the OP theme), and I can’t emphasise enough how much I like Daichi as a main protagonist, and for this type of series especially. He’s just so relentlessly and proactively optimistic that I can’t help but find myself charmed. On the other hand, the copious amounts of technobabble got old pretty quickly, and the sexist clichés got old even quicker. I made a note of this last time, but it’s still really bothering me; the ongoing trend of having female antagonists portrayed as sexually assertive and vivacious, while female protagonists are portrayed as sweetly naïve and/or sexually impotent, is something I find very problematic indeed – not to mention just plain annoying. We have Hana as the Good Girl, bedecked in a flowy, pure-white summer dress and equipped with as much bodily/sexual awareness as a toddler – the latter of which is of course played out just for laughs. Akari, as the Other but not Main Good Girl, tries to be sexy but fails miserably since she looks about 10 years old – again, played for the comedic value. And then we have Moco as the Evil Girl, who therefore has to flirt her way to her goals while stuffed into high-heel shoes, thigh-high stockings with suspenders, short shorts, and a tiny bustier to hold up her constantly jiggling melon-breasts. It’s hardly subtle stuff, and I credited the team behind Captain Earth with a bit more intelligence than that. Perhaps I was wrong to do so.

Sidonia no Kishi/Knights of Sidonia
Original score: none
Score: 7.5/10

49. picture2

Wow. So, despite picking up this series on a whim, and despite not being overly fond of space-centric science fiction, there’s a lot about Sidonia no Kishi that I like. The character designs are cool, and I especially dig the uniforms. I appreciate that technobabble is kept fairly minimal, and I appreciate the general lack of fanservice even more. I love the OP theme (definitely the best single from angela I’ve heard in a while), although the ED is pretty good too. I also think that having these mecha that basically anyone can pilot, given enough skill and practice, rather than having only a few special ‘chosen ones’ with the inherent ability to do so, is an excellent move. One of the only things I’m not completely sold on is the CG; while I don’t have anything against the style, character movements look quite stiff and stilted, and can be distracting. I think that’s actually a relatively minor complaint though, and depending on how the plot progresses and what the pacing is like, I may well even bump the score up a bit later on. A lot of people seem to be comparing this show to Shingeki no Kyojin and I can sort of see why, although the similarities appear only skin-deep to me. And either way, Sidonia no Kishi is already proving itself to be the far stronger title.

Isshuukan Friends/One Week Friends
Original score: 8/10
Current score: 8/10

46. picture12

Now this is how to do a heart-warmingly sweet yet beautifully solid slice-of-life romance. It’s technically a drama, sure, but the cheap melodrama that characterises so many other romance titles is nowhere to be seen here – and by this point, I trust that Isshuukan Friends is smart enough to continue keeping those absurd misunderstandings, overly emotional knee-jerk reactions, and impassioned theatrics well out of the picture. It’s a simple anime with some simple messages, but it’s also reasonably powerful at what it does and quite lovely just the way it is. Better yet, it’s a romance that’s first and foremost about building and maintaining friendships rather than one about dating, sex, love triangles, or really anything else. Not that there’s anything intrinsically wrong or bad about any these other things, but it’s beyond refreshing to see a romance title whose primary focus is on none of them. I have one or two extremely minor complaints (which I’ll address if I end up writing up a full review once the anime is done), but this is still easily one of the best shows of the season.

Mushishi Zoku Shou
Original score: 10/10
Current score: 10/10

46. picture13

Honestly, nothing I say could properly express how good I feel this series is. I accept that Mushishi isn’t a show that absolutely everyone will or even should enjoy, but I also think its all-around excellence speaks for itself. As such, I really have nothing else to say – it is, quite simply, one of the finest anime of all time. As there are no particular changes of any kind as far as this sequel goes, and because it’s a purely episodic title, new viewers will have no problem diving straight in if they’re so inclined.

Question of the post: What are your top three picks of the spring anime season, and are they still the same titles as they were when the season had just started?

10 thoughts on “Anime Taste Testing: Spring 2014 (Part II)

  1. My top three title hadn’t changed since the beginning: Ping Pong, Mushishi, Isshuukan Friends, in no particular order.

    Yes, there are weeks one of them might not make top 3 (such as this week feeling Mushishi was a bit weaker, and NGNL much stronger than usual, or 1st episode of Captain Earth getting #1 spot), but in general, these three are the best currently airing shows I’m watching, and it doesn’t seem like it’d change anytime soon.

    You know, we’ve talked of it, and it also came up elsewhere, it’s somewhat interesting I’m pegged as a Mahouka hater when I’ve actually been responsible for quite a few people not dropping it as they wait for the next arc, which I assure them is better. I also think the anime is better than the source material, as it cuts away a lot of the info-dumps/chatter.

    If I had to say what I do absolutely hate about the anime, it’s the Visual Novel or “Elevator Music” style music playing everywhere that just seems so ill-fitting, almost hilariously so.

    I’ve put Captain Earth on hold. Marathon it when it ends is my plan. I might watch Star Driver in the meanwhile once I’m done with a couple of backlog shows I’m currently watching. But yeah, Mushishi, Isshuukan Friends, and Ping Pong are enough to keep me busy this season, and I’ve got a whole bunch more stuff I enjoy to some degree.

    Black Bullet is done with the first arc, and so is NGNL, so this is the real test – many adaptations stumble after the first arc, or truly take off. So now we need to see how they handle it.

    Mekakucity Actors – I am so close to dropping it every episode. This episode actually felt weak to me, so much weaker than the song it’s based on… it’s really interesting to think of. Meh.


    1. Yeah, now that every anime has had a chance to properly settle in, I doubt I’ll be seeing any change to my top 3 either.

      I doubt I’ll be dropping either Captain Earth or Black Bullet unless one or both of them does something to really piss me off, and Kamigami no Asobi is my fangirl hilarity of the season, which only leaves Mahouka. I’ve decided to give Mahouka one more episode, since presumably it’ll be a bit more exciting (or try to be, anyway) than previous episodes. If it still doesn’t do anything for me even so, then I’ll know it’ll be a waste of my time to watch further.


  2. I’m glad to see you decided to give Sidonia a try in spite of your indifference toward SF. It’s become one of the three outstanding series (Mushishi and Ping Pong are the others) this season for me.

    But I am sooo close to dropping Mahouka. Yes, I understand that “it gets better,” or at least the books do. But I am disgusted by the moral viewpoints of the main characters, so I’m actually rooting for the bad guys now. Maybe that’s the point; I don’t know.


    1. Me too, absolutely. I’m feeling pretty confident that Sidonia will likewise be in my top 3 for the remainder of the season, alongside Mushishi and Isshuukan Friends.

      As I told Guy just now, I’m giving Mahouka exactly one more episode to try and win my attention over, as the upcoming episode is (allegedly) set up to be a bit more exciting and action-orientated than previous ones. If it fails to entertain me in some fashion even still, then I’m out. Regardless of whether things get better after that or not, my patience will only stretch so far.


  3. My top three picks would be:

    One week friends; I really like the characters and overall look and feel of the show. I like how the characters interact and the pacing is just right. It’s not going to fast and knows when to pull the viewer back in. This show is steadily progressing and is true to the feel of the first episode.

    Hitsugi no Chaika; Chaika is a really good character(I know you think otherwise), but I think she is well created with her words and mannerisms. The visual design is steady and BONES delivers good shows overall.

    Love Live S2; It’s super cute and I liked the previous season so this was an obvious choice for me. It’s true the theme and to the first season with a diverse set of characters that gives the studio room to play with.


    1. Well, you already know my opinions on Chaika so I won’t repeat them, and you probably also know that idol shows really aren’t my thing at all, but it looks like we have Isshuukan Friends in common at least. Actually, I have yet to hear a person say they dislike that show. No argument here – it’s a gorgeous anime with a lot of heart.


  4. Nice overview of some of the main titles this season! I really agree with your assessments of Black Bullet, Captain Earth, and Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei… They all look very pretty, but I’m not connecting with their characters or stories very much. Also, nice to hear you tried out Knights of Sidonia!

    My top three picks would be:

    Gochuumon wa Usagi Desu ka? : Relaxing, cute, funny, and simple, this show wasn’t really on my radar at the start of the season, but I find it’s an anime that knows exactly what it’s doing and that makes no attempts to be anything more than what it is. It’s just cute girls doing cute things, simple as that.

    Knights of Sidonia : Don’t love the CG either, but I am enjoying the “hard sci-fi” feeling of the show and how gritty things look as opposed to the shiny, clean future generally portrayed in anime. There’s plenty of mystery to unravel, and I’m looking forward to seeing more plot and character development.

    Mushishi Zoku Shou : It’s Mushishi… need I say more? :p


    1. I feel like I’ve completely exhausted my ‘cute girls doing cute things’ quota for the next several months at least – I only like that sort of thing in moderation, or I start getting cavities – but it does indeed look like a cute show. Who knows, maybe I’ll get around to it at some point.

      You’ll get no argument from me about either Knights of Sidonia or Mushishi; both great shows with a very strong presence, and I don’t foresee either of them losing their spot among my top 3 titles of the spring season.


  5. My top three:

    Isshuukan Friends – This series, I was a bit late to the game for, but I picked it up after hearing good things about it, and found that it’s just the sort of anime I’ve been trying to find for quite some time. A solid, heartfelt love story, with a good setup and surprisingly mature writing. The cast is small, but the characters are complex and presented well enough to carry the series by themselves. I like how the main characters are more subdued and realistic in their personalities, but still distinct on their own right.

    Mekakucity Actors – I’m sorry, please don’t hurt me! It seems I’m in something of a minority in liking this anime, but I can’t help myself. I guess when you get right down to it, the style is just something that appeals to me, but I found that it has merits on its own right. Many of the choices made in the presentation are a clear shot at being artistic, but I happen to like artsy things like this enough to get into it, and I also really dig the upbeat tone. The various dream sequences, for one thing, are just flat out cool, and it brings up some interesting concepts. It does have some problems I can quip about, but it’s still a good, solid show.

    Mushishi – Because of course it’s in my top three.


    1. I completely agree about Isshuukan Friends, and of course Mushishi, which really needs no explanation.

      To be clear, I don’t hate Mekakucity Actors – I just thought it was mediocre. Mostly I stopped watching because it felt like it was trying way too hard to be cool and artsy, when in fact it came across to me as nothing but pretentious and self-indulgent. However, you’re perfectly entitled to your opinion – while I’ll happily critisise an anime itself, I’m not about to critisise someone for their personal tastes.



Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s