I figured that after how much I liked Banana Fish, it must be time for the somewhat less enjoyable stuff. I sure wasn’t wrong.
Kyoto Teramachi Sanjou no Holmes/Holmes at Kyoto Teramachi Sanjou
While largely inoffensive, I honestly can’t think of much reason to praise Holmes. And I’m not particularly surprised – can anyone think of any anime title or anime character named after the famous detective that turned out even halfway decent? I get the Japanese pun and all, and can even sort of appreciate that Kiyotaka isn’t actually the one who gave himself the nickname (though he does refer to himself as a “nasty Kyoto boy”, so there is that). However, the fact that it’s included as part of the show at all baffles me; it seems not only pointless but detrimental to the series as a whole. Invoke a name like Holmes and you’re going to invite comparisons, deserved or not – and most of them will probably not be flattering. Anyhow, for the most part I found myself profoundly bored by proceedings, and unless you happen to be really into Japanese antiques, I can’t see Holmes being a hit with any viewer, least of all die-hard mystery/Sherlock Holmes fans. It certainly doesn’t help that the show looks incredibly cheap, from the generic character designs and oversaturated colour palette to the extremely shoddy background art and poorly-animated movement. My advice is to skip over this one unless you need some help getting to sleep – in which case, go for it, you might just be in luck.
Phantom in the Twilight
This could probably be worse. Actually, I know it could be worse, because our main heroine wasn’t threatened, abused, or assaulted by any of the resident vampire (?) bishounen, and also she had like actual thoughts and opinions and stuff. That doesn’t make Phantom in the Twilight in any way a good series though, and this first episode forced me to ask myself some pretty deep questions. Questions such as “who funded this?”, and “why?” Granted, the source material could be considerably better for all I know, so I suppose I’d better not hastily judge the entire- OH WAIT IT’S AN ANIME ORIGINAL NEVER MIND. From beginning to end, this is just plain bad storytelling – an unoriginal and uninspired story with dialogue bogged down in clumsy exposition and with noticeably cheap animation to boot. Even the male character designs aren’t all pretty in the least, which bewilders me a bit – why make the girls look good and then draw the guys (i.e. the main purpose of the anime) so lazily that not only are they unappealing, but a couple of them look like completely different characters from scene to scene? At one point during the episode, I briefly entertained the notion that the whole thing might be a parody, so crap it was actually intentional. Then I realised this was giving the show way too much credit, and it really was just that bad.
Question of the post: Did you watch either of these shows and if so, what are your thoughts?
8 thoughts on “Anime Taste Testing: Kyoto Teramachi Sanjou no Holmes and Phantom in the Twilight”
I watched both shows, and I remember thinking they were both kind of sort of okayish, but not memorable, so I don’t really know what to say. (I also saw the second ep of Banana Fish today, and am unsure if I want to continue. It has its good points, and I’ll definitely try ep3.)
I’ve got a few shows I like this season, but nothing all that special. I’m still pinning my hope on that Tsukumogami show, but the preview doesn’t make it look special either. Any more plans on your side? This is perhaps the hardest season to find new stuff for me since winter 2013 (which was saved by second cours).
I’ve definitely seen worse anime than both of these shows (though I guess who hasn’t?), but even so, neither managed to impress me. I do have some more reviews coming out though, and like you, will also be trying out Tsukumogami. I’m also interested in Muhyo to Rouji no Mahouritsu Soudan Jimusho, which I believe is scheduled for an early August premiere.
Yeesh, that last one sounded horrible. Not my genre anyway, but even so.
It might possibly have been my genre, once upon a time, but I’d like to think even my 15-year old self had some standards.
Will you be looking at Free! S3- Dive to the Future? The animation quality is still as good, and the new director gives a more focused hand to the proceedings.
I understand watching the prequel movie, Hish Speed, and the transitionary movie Take Your Marks are needed to give context for S3’s events though.
Yes, I’ll absolutely be taking a look at the third season of Free. Expect that post to be up sometime in the next day or so.