Anime Taste Testing: Magia Record: Mahou Shoujo Madoka☆Magica Gaiden

Magia Record feels like if this next instalment Madoka Magica franchise had secretly been directed by Sato Junichi (of Sailor Moon, Princess Tutu and Kaleido Star fame). And man, wouldn’t that have been something.

I’m really in two minds about this opening episode. Now I’m firmly of the belief that unless a show is a direct sequel to (and features the same primary cast as) the original, it should be judged entirely on its own merits, with little to no comparison in terms of rating to its earlier incarnation. The issue with Magia Record is that this is all but impossible. On the one hand, while definitely a sequel that I guess takes place in the same timeline (look, it’s been a while, and I never watched the films at all), most of the main characters are brand new and even the production staff are mostly comprised of different faces. On the other hand, there are so many call-backs to the Madoka Magica that you just can’t avoid making those comparisons even if you wanted to, from the return of Kyuubey to the nearly-identical surrealist art style.

And the problem is, I’m not even sure if Magia Record would work on its own as far as the story goes. You don’t need to be intensely familiar with the plot of the first Madoka Magica to appreciate the story here (I mean, I haven’t re-watched the series in its entirety even once since it came out), but I imagine anyone going in to Magia Record completely cold would be hella confused by the events taking place; having at least some prior knowledge of the franchise definitely feels like a necessity.

Moreover, as far as being a follow-up to Madoka Magica goes, Magia Record just doesn’t quite match it, in either quality or content. The former worked so well exactly because it was unexpected – it felt unsettling to watch, but viewers didn’t necessarily know why, and that’s what made it such a gut punch when shit eventually did hit the fan, so to speak. This time, viewers know precisely what to expect (not that Magia Record is going to any pains whatsoever to be subtle about its darker side), and that takes away much of its emotional impact. It would be like watching a perfectly decent horror or thriller movie for the first time if you nonetheless somehow knew every single plot twist and jump scare beforehand.

So overall, what do I think of the opening episode of Magia Record? It’s… fine. Not bad at all, just fine. And that’s probably okay. Just don’t expect to be surprised, pleasantly or otherwise.

Rating: 6/10

7 thoughts

  1. That was more or less how I felt watching the episode. It doesn’t have the benefit of surprise and doesn’t off much else other than feeling kind of like Madoka did but less subtle about it. That said, I enjoyed the episode enough and I plan to keep watching.

    Like

    1. I did wonder how it came off to other viewers – I rarely look up other first impression reviews before writing my own, so it’s nearly always a mystery until people comment on these posts, haha.

      Yes, for now, I plan on continuing to watch too, at least for another episode or so. I’ll likely have a firmer idea then how I feel about the show.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Sure, I did plan to give it another episode or so. But I’ll definitely be picky when it comes to anime, because I just don’t have time to give several episodes to every anime that /might have potential.

      Like

  2. I feel pretty much the same way about this episode. This is what happened: I, wary, push the start button. They play the magical girl theme and a pink haired girl is walking. I’m watching this with a decidedly unimpressed face. Later: yeah, that’s a witch. But the show is pretty, and has some genuinely good shots, and the characters, even though nearly everyone being some sort of throwback, hold their own enogh to work on their own, so by the end of the episode I was kind-of half charmed by the show, despite starting out with a cynical franchise-exploitation mind frame (I didn’t like Rebellion; Rebellion doesn’t exist). I think I’ll at least be able to enjoy this.

    Like

    1. It just feels all… well, derivative to me, which I guess it is. That’s more or less unavoidable in a sequel, but I can’t help but be swayed by that. But hey, I’ll guve it another episode or two before making up my mind on this one.

      Like

LEAVE A COMMENT

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s